Thinking

Chapter 9 - THE MAN WHO NEVER EXISTED

We raced down the stairs and out the front door. Margaret’s car was gone. The driveway was empty. I stood there, breathless, staring at the empty road, my heart hammering so hard I thought I might collapse.

"Where would she take him?" I demanded, turning to Daniel. "Where does she keep Elias hidden?"

Daniel stood frozen, his face pale, staring into the distance. I grabbed his arm.

"Daniel! Tell me! Where does she go when she vanishes for hours? When she says she’s visiting friends or going to church? Where?"

He blinked, as if waking from a trance.

"The cottage," he said. "The old hunting cottage deep in the woods on the far edge of the property. She said it was too run-down to use. That it should be left to rot. But lately… she’s been going there more often. Taking supplies. Food. Clothes."

He looked at me, his eyes filled with horror.

"I never asked why. I thought she was sentimental. I thought she was visiting memories."

"She was visiting him," I said. "And now she has taken our son there."

We drove in silence, speeding down narrow, winding roads that cut deep into the forest. Every second felt like an hour. Every bend hid a new terror. Noah was with Margaret. With Elias. The man I had seen only in that grainy photograph. The man who had come to me once, in grief, and then vanished. The man who was his father.

I gripped the handhold until my fingers ached.

"Tell me about him," I said. "About Elias. Before he 'died'. What was he truly like?"

Daniel stared straight ahead at the road.

"Charming," he said quietly. "Brilliant. Wild. Everything I was not. People loved him instantly. But he was also… cruel. In the way that powerful people can be cruel without even trying. He took what he wanted. And when he grew tired of things… he discarded them. Including people."

He glanced at me.

"Mother worshipped him. She always said Elias was born to rule. That I was… steady. Reliable. But never the heir. Never the true son."

"And then he 'died'," I said.

"And then he died," Daniel repeated. "And everything became mine. The house. The name. The inheritance. Even you, Adrian. Mother pushed us together. She said you needed stability. She said I would make you happy."

He let out a short, bitter breath.

"All along… she was saving me for a backup plan. If Elias couldn’t have you… I would."

The words hung in the car, heavy and cold. Margaret had arranged everything. My marriage to Daniel. Noah’s place in the family. The will. The trust. All of it had been a carefully constructed web of lies, designed to protect her favorite son and preserve his claim on everything.

The cottage appeared through the trees. Small. Weathered. Smoke curling gently from the stone chimney. It looked peaceful. Innocent.

Daniel cut the engine a short distance away. We got out and moved quietly through the trees, staying low, keeping out of sight.

From behind a large oak, we watched the porch.

The door opened. Margaret stepped out. She looked back over her shoulder, speaking to someone inside. Then she turned and walked down the path toward the garden, her posture relaxed, unhurried.

And then he appeared in the doorway.

Elias.

He looked exactly like Daniel—older, harder, sharper around the edges. But it was his eyes that made my breath catch. They were Noah’s eyes. Bright. Clear. Familiar. And he stood there, resting his hand on the doorframe, watching Margaret walk away, with a look of such quiet arrogance that it made my skin crawl.

Then he turned back inside.

And a moment later, I saw Noah.

He stood in the doorway, clutching his dinosaur pillow to his chest, staring up at Elias. Elias crouched down. He said something. Noah hesitated. Then he took Elias’s hand.

My knees gave way. I caught myself against the tree trunk.

"He has him," I whispered. "He has him."

Daniel took a step forward, but I held him back.

"Wait," I whispered. "Margaret is out there. And Elias… we don’t know what he will do. We need to hear what they say. We need to know what he intends."

We crept closer, hiding beside the open window, listening.

Elias’s voice drifted out, deep and warm.

"You have my eyes, little one," he was saying. "And my chin. Everyone will see it soon enough. They will know exactly who you belong to."

Noah’s voice trembled.

"Grandma said you went away. That you were sick."

"I was away," Elias said smoothly. "But now I am home. And everything your mother and your uncle Daniel think is yours… actually belongs to me. And to you. Because we are blood. Real blood."

"My home is with Mommy," Noah said.

Elias laughed softly.

"Your mother is a lovely woman. But she was always meant to be mine. Not Daniel’s. And now… you are mine too. We will be a family. Just as your grandmother always planned."

I felt Daniel tense beside me. His hand gripped the window sill so hard the wood creaked.

Elias continued.

"Once we sign the papers, once everything is in our names… we will send Daniel away. And your mother? She will learn to love me properly. Or she will learn to be quiet. Either way… you will be raised as my son. And no one will ever dare say you don’t belong again."

I clamped a hand over my mouth to muffle a sob. This was never about protecting Noah. It was about power. About reclaiming what Margaret believed Elias had been cheated out of. About rewriting history so that her favorite son got everything—his brother’s wife, his brother’s fortune, his brother’s child.

They were going to erase Daniel entirely. And force me to rebuild my life beside the man who had abandoned me years before.

Daniel stepped away from the window. He looked at me, his face set in stone.

"He intends to take everything," Daniel whispered. "Including you. And he will use Noah to do it."

"Then we cannot let him keep Noah," I said. "Not for one more minute."

Daniel nodded slowly.

"I will go around the back," he said. "Create a distraction. Get Elias away from the door. When he moves… you take Noah. Run. Don’t look back. Get to the car and drive away. I will follow."

"And you?" I asked.

May you like

Daniel looked toward the window, where Elias’s shadow moved across the wall.

"I have a few things to say to my brother," he said quietly. "Things I should have said years ago."

Related Stories

Other posts